A Portrait of Muslim Britain
Despite facing systemic economic disadvantages and holding distinct social conservatism, British Muslims demonstrate a profound sense of national belonging, civic engagement, and trust in public institutions.
AUTHORS
Pickthall House
PUBLISHED
August 13, 2024
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Demographics
2. Politics
3. Patriotism and Identity
4. Media and conspiracy theories
5. Civil society
6. Society
7. Education
8. Language
9. Crime
10. Extremism
11. Wealth
12. Health
13. Conclusions
KEY FINDINGS
- British Muslims are a young, highly diverse demographic that reports overwhelmingly strong feelings of national belonging and freedom to practice their faith, factors which have significantly aided their integration.
- The community actively participates in civil society and largely shares the broader public's domestic priorities—such as the NHS and the cost of living—while nearly unanimously condemning political extremism and violence.
- Many Muslims experience severe socioeconomic hurdles, including high rates of overcrowded housing, lower social mobility, and overrepresentation in the prison population, challenges that are notably concentrated in highly deprived areas.
Demographics
The 2021 census recorded approximately 3.9 million Muslims in England and Wales, representing 6.5% of the population. This demographic is notably young, with 84.5% of British Muslims under the age of 50, compared to just 62% of the general population. The Muslim community is ethnically diverse, predominantly consisting of Asian or Asian British individuals—particularly those of Pakistani and Bangladeshi descent—though it also includes significant Black African and White populations. This diversity means the community is not a monolithic bloc, but rather a complex lattice of sub-communities.
Politics
The political concerns of British Muslims largely align with the wider public, focusing heavily on domestic issues such as the NHS, unemployment, the economy, and the cost of living crisis. While international affairs, particularly the Israel-Gaza war, are ranked higher in importance by Muslims compared to the general public, this does not contradict their strong sense of British identity or domestic engagement. Recent reports of sectarian voting overlook the fact that changes in voting patterns often reflect broader discontent in deprived areas rather than single-issue religious voting.
Patriotism and Identity
A vast majority of British Muslims feel a profound sense of national belonging, with 71.7% identifying solely as British. Over half of Muslims consider their national identity important to their sense of self, a rate higher than the general adult population. This strong attachment exists despite the fact that around 49% of British Muslims were born overseas, indicating that immigrants quickly develop a robust British identity. Furthermore, Muslims overwhelmingly feel free to practice their religion in Britain, which acts as a crucial foundation for this national loyalty and integration.
Media and conspiracy theories
Trust in mainstream media is notably low among British Muslims, with many believing the media portrays them too negatively. This lack of trust occasionally correlates with higher susceptibility to conspiracy theories, such as varying beliefs regarding the perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks. Despite these suspicions of media bias, the community remains eager for integration and fair representation.
Civil society
British Muslims demonstrate a robust appetite for civic engagement and integration, showing higher rates of voting, charitable fundraising, and local volunteering than the wider public. A majority of Muslims express a desire to fully integrate with non-Muslims in all aspects of life, and younger Muslims frequently maintain diverse, multi-ethnic friendship groups.
Society
While Muslims in Britain often hold more socially conservative views than the general public, such as on issues of gender segregation in schools or homosexuality, this conservatism does not diminish their sense of national belonging. The data indicates that British identity can comfortably encompass a wide range of social attitudes, and many conservative values held by Muslims align with older traditional British values rather than being inherently un-British.
Education
Education is highly valued within the Muslim community, with Muslims forming a larger proportion of students than any other religious group. Around 32.3% of Muslims hold a degree-level qualification, closely mirroring the national average, though this varies significantly among different ethnic subgroups. Additionally, there is strong support among Muslims for a common national curriculum to enhance cohesion, as well as a surprising openness to government regulation and training for after-school madrasa tutors, reflecting trust in civic institutions.
Language
While the majority of British Muslims speak English as their main language, a significant minority face language barriers. Around 1.54% of Muslims in England and Wales cannot speak English at all, a challenge most prevalent among first-generation immigrants from specific countries like Syria, Kuwait, and Afghanistan. The community also exhibits immense linguistic diversity, with Urdu, Bengali, Arabic, and Somali being among the most common secondary main languages.
Crime
Crime is a significant concern for Muslim voters, compounded by the uncomfortable reality that Muslims comprise around 18% of the prison population in England and Wales. Despite these issues and feelings among some that the police treat Muslims unfairly, a majority of Muslims still believe the police do a good job and actually support placing more police officers on the streets to combat crime.
Extremism
There is near-unanimous condemnation of extremist violence and terrorism within the British Muslim community, often at rates higher than the general population. Interestingly, greater religiosity and social conservatism do not correlate with political radicalism. While counter-extremism programs like Prevent face criticism from vocal community factions, a quiet majority of Muslims express support for the general principles of such policies.
Wealth
British Muslims face significant socioeconomic disadvantages, being nearly four times as likely to live in overcrowded housing and much more likely to rely on social renting compared to the broader population. A considerable portion of the Muslim population resides in some of the most deprived areas of England and Wales, experiencing stalled social mobility over the past two decades. Remarkably, this financial disenfranchisement has not prevented the community from developing a strong affinity and loyalty to Britain.
Health
Based on self-reporting, Muslims are slightly less likely to report having bad or very bad health compared to the general population, likely due to the community's younger average age. However, health issues are notably worse among older Muslims, particularly women over 65, who report significantly higher rates of poor health and daily activity limitations than their peers in the wider public. Consequently, healthcare and the NHS remain top priorities for Muslim voters.
Conclusions
British Muslims maintain a conscious, articulated identification with Britain and demonstrate deep investment in its civic institutions, despite facing inequalities in wealth and crime. Freedom of religion and state non-interference have been critical in fostering this successful integration, contrasting sharply with the assimilationist policies of other European nations. Ultimately, addressing the community's challenges requires acknowledging the role of economic deprivation, which Muslims often share with the White British working class, to ensure balanced and evidence-based policymaking.
