At the Tropical Crossroads
To ensure its green energy transition and post-Brexit economic sovereignty, Britain must forge a robust bilateral trade partnership with Indonesia to secure the massive nickel reserves essential for battery production.
AUTHORS
Pickthall House
PUBLISHED
March 30, 2024
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Abstract
2. On Taking Back Control
3. On National Goals
4. On Greenification
5. On Battery Storage
6. What is the size of this market?
7. How are these batteries produced?
8. On Nickel
9. On Indonesia and Opportunity
10. On Risks
KEY FINDINGS
- Britain's post-Brexit green energy transition relies on scaling domestic battery gigafactories, which requires massive, reliable nickel supplies.
- Dependence on volatile foreign supply chains and imported batteries threatens UK energy security and risks tariff penalties on EU electric vehicle exports.
- Britain must urgently pursue a bilateral trade partnership with Indonesiathe world's largest nickel supplierto secure these critical minerals and unlock a rapidly growing market.
Abstract
Following the Brexit vote to re-establish national sovereignty, Britain must clearly define its national interests, focusing heavily on the electrification of the economy and the development of green technology. The large-scale production of batteries via gigafactories is crucial for this transition, requiring long-term, reliable sources of nickel. Indonesia, a rapidly growing nation that exports most of the world's nickel, is currently pursuing domestic development by moving up the value chain and banning raw ore exports. Britain has a significant opportunity to advance its electrification, trade, and diplomatic interests by establishing an enhanced bilateral relationship with Indonesia, a market it currently underutilizes.
On Taking Back Control
The Brexit campaign's "Take Back Control" slogan symbolized a desire for national sovereignty, autonomy, and freedom from European bureaucracy. Despite formally leaving the EU in 2020, domestic political turmoil and policy failures, such as net migration increasing despite promises of border control, have left the nation feeling stultified. Because the UK democratically chose to exercise its agency, it remains rational and politically expedient to actively forge new industrial, immigration, and foreign policies that serve its specific national interests.
On National Goals
Britain must rationally assess its national interests and establish clear priorities before formulating strategy. Based on the intersection of recent Conservative and Labour party manifestos, Britain's cross-party national goals include tackling crime, improving healthcare efficiency, maintaining border control, delivering higher quality education, and launching a massive expansion in green energy provision.
On Greenification
Clean energy security is fundamental to Britain's future strategy, requiring multifaceted institutional efforts that leverage the nation's existing strengths. UK transport and power generation account for 26% and 20% of emissions, respectively, highlighting the critical need for targeted decarbonization. Britain possesses a comparative advantage in sectors vital to the energy transition, such as financial, scientific, and technical services, which serve as prime inputs for green capital projects. Within this framework, battery technology and production stand out as commercially viable, well-understood, and critical components of the energy transition that must be deployed at scale.
On Battery Storage
Large-scale commercial batteries are essential both for Electric Vehicles (EVs) and Grid-Scale Battery Energy Storage Systems (BESS), which are needed to balance the seasonal and daily fluctuations of renewable energy sources. The global demand for lithium-ion batteries is projected to grow by over 30% annually, reaching a market size of 4.7TWh and a value exceeding $400 billion by 2030. The UK Government's Battery Strategy aims to capture this growth through targeted support for EV production, research funding, expanding mineral market access, and international collaboration. Britain is uniquely positioned to succeed in this sector due to its outsized role in global R&D, its status as the fourth-largest battery startup ecosystem, and its large domestic car manufacturing industry.
On Battery Production
Battery infrastructure accounts for approximately half the cost of EV production, with the predominant costs stemming from cell inputs like lithium, nickel, cobalt, and graphite. Current mineral supply chains are highly strained, opaque, and concentrated, making them vulnerable to geopolitical and logistical disruptions. Furthermore, the UK's current reliance on imported batteries, particularly from China, risks causing UK automakers to fail Rules of Origin (RoO) requirements, which could severely hinder tariff-free EV exports to the European Union.
On Nickel
Nickel is a crucial component for producing high energy-density cathodes, which allow for the creation of high-quality, lightweight electric vehicle batteries. Russia is a major supplier of high-purity Class 1 nickel, and its invasion of Ukraine has caused significant market disruptions, increasing the mineral's strategic criticality for the West. Battery production's share of global nickel demand is expected to continue rising dramatically over the coming decade, driven heavily by an industry shift toward low-cobalt/high-nickel cathode materials.
On Indonesia and Opportunity
Indonesia is a rapidly developing economy with the world's fourth-largest population and is projected to become the fourth-largest global economy by 2050. The country holds the world's largest supplies of raw nickel but has enacted bans on raw exports to force foreign investment into local processing and technology, resulting in an ongoing WTO dispute with the EU. Despite Indonesia's massive market size and strategic resources, gross trade with the UK currently accounts for a paltry 0.2% of British foreign trade. The UK must rectify this underutilization by securing critical mineral supplies and expanding trade partnerships with Indonesia, building upon precedents like the Joint Economic Trade Committee and existing joint ventures.
On Risks
Potential technological shifts, such as the commercialization of Sodium-Ion batteries, could eventually reduce nickel demand, but Indonesia's massive and rapidly expanding local market still renders a comprehensive trade partnership highly attractive for the UK. Past industrial failures in the UK, such as the high-profile bankruptcy of British Volt, should not deter the nation from pursuing necessary, future-proof industrial policies and high-tech ventures. Securing the critical infrastructure required for global decarbonization demands that the UK accept reasonable risks and actively experiment rather than defaulting to cautious or previously failed policies.
