WHITE PAPERS

Palestine

Britain and the Arab-Israeli Conflict

Britain's unequivocal support for Israel's war on Gaza contradicts its historical neutrality and official foreign policy, severely damaging its diplomatic credibility and strategic relations within the Muslim world. To avoid a permanent loss of soft power and regional influence, this report urges Britain to abandon this unconditional support and return to an even-handed approach rooted in international law and the pursuit of a two-state solution.

AUTHORS

Pickthall House

PUBLISHED

February 19, 2024

PDF
TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. Britain's official policy on Israel and the occupation

2. Britain's support for Israel's war in Gaza and the Muslim world's approach

3. Damage to Britain's reputation in the Muslim world

4. Potential implications

5. Charting a new course

KEY FINDINGS
  • In recent years, successive British governments have undermined Britain’s official foreign policy towards Israel and this directly contradicts its historical diplomatic neutrality and official support for a two-state solution.
  • This partisan approach is rapidly destroying Britain's credibility, soft power, and strategic relationships across the Muslim world and the Global South.
  • A cautious approach to the Arab-Israeli conflict, committed to international law and focussed on securing a lasting peace between Israelis, Palestinians and the wider region, is of vital importance in maintaining Britain’s international stature.

Britain's official policy on Israel and the occupation

The UK officially supports a two-state solution based on 1967 lines and considers Israeli settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territories illegal. However, recent actions by successive British governments, such as proposing to move the embassy to Jerusalem and passing the Economic Activity of Public Bodies Bill to outlaw Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS), contradict this longstanding non-partisan stance. Furthermore, Britain's failure to challenge the Israeli government's explicit opposition to a Palestinian state has led the international community to view the UK as biased rather than neutral.  

Britain's support for Israel's war in Gaza and the Muslim world's approach

Historically, Britain maintained diplomatic neutrality during Middle Eastern conflicts, such as the 1973 Yom Kippur War, to balance relations between Israel and Arab nations. In contrast, the current UK government has offered unequivocal support to Israel during the Gaza war, deployed a naval task force, and abstained from UN resolutions calling for humanitarian pauses. This alignment with US policy places Britain in direct opposition to major Muslim allies—including Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and Turkey—who are actively pushing for ceasefires and a two-state solution.  

Damage to Britain's reputation in the Muslim world

Britain's unconditional backing of Israel is severely damaging its international reputation and relationship with Arab governments. Western nations are facing accusations of hypocrisy from the Global South, with diplomats noting a stark contrast between the West's condemnation of Russian actions in Ukraine and its tolerance of Israeli actions in Gaza. Consequently, elites in non-Western countries and Arab diplomats feel alienated, warning that trust in American and British mediation has been deeply compromised.  

Potential implications

The growing anger among Muslim nations over Britain's stance risks a permanent loss of British soft power and international credibility. Experts warn that this perceived hypocrisy undermines Western legitimacy, simultaneously creating geopolitical opportunities for Russia and China to boost their influence in the Global South. Additionally, unconditional Western support may inadvertently extend the conflict by potentially renewing local support for Hamas, further imperiling the prospect of peace.  

Charting a new course

Britain's unequivocal support for Israel is increasing the likelihood of conflict and exposing vulnerabilities in the UK's underfunded military infrastructure. To protect its security interests and regional stability, Britain must transition away from unconditional support and reassess its Middle Eastern strategy. Ultimately, the UK should adopt a cautious, even-handed approach committed to international law and the realization of Palestinian statehood to restore its diplomatic stature.  

‍